{
  "scenario": "S24",
  "pass": true,
  "expected_verdict": "RED",
  "actual_verdict": "RED",
  "expected_red_reason": "Issue #318 — MCP stdio writes bypass federation fanout (closes in Patch 2)",
  "run_id": "20260503162135-3832",
  "namespace": "test/S24/20260503162135-3832",
  "outputs": {
    "phase1_http_replication_ok": true,
    "phase1_peer_counts": {
      "node-2": 1,
      "node-3": 1,
      "node-4": 1
    },
    "phase2_mcp_replication_per_tool": {
      "memory_store": 0,
      "memory_update": 0,
      "memory_delete": 0,
      "memory_link": 0,
      "memory_promote": 0,
      "memory_consolidate": 0,
      "memory_forget": 0
    },
    "phase2_mcp_replication_per_tool_per_peer": {
      "memory_store": {
        "node-2": 0,
        "node-3": 0,
        "node-4": 0
      },
      "memory_update": {
        "node-2": 0,
        "node-3": 0,
        "node-4": 0
      },
      "memory_delete": {
        "node-2": 0,
        "node-3": 0,
        "node-4": 0
      },
      "memory_link": {
        "node-2": 0,
        "node-3": 0,
        "node-4": 0
      },
      "memory_promote": {
        "node-2": 0,
        "node-3": 0,
        "node-4": 0
      },
      "memory_consolidate": {
        "node-2": 0,
        "node-3": 0,
        "node-4": 0
      },
      "memory_forget": {
        "node-2": 0,
        "node-3": 0,
        "node-4": 0
      }
    },
    "phase2_local_audit_present": false,
    "phase2_local_counts": {
      "memory_store": 0,
      "memory_update": 0,
      "memory_delete": 0,
      "memory_link": 0,
      "memory_promote": 0,
      "memory_consolidate": 0,
      "memory_forget": 0
    },
    "tools_probed": [
      "memory_store",
      "memory_update",
      "memory_delete",
      "memory_link",
      "memory_promote",
      "memory_consolidate",
      "memory_forget"
    ]
  },
  "reasons": [
    "phase 2 writes not all visible on NODE_A locally — some MCP stdio calls failed; verdict may not reflect #318 cleanly"
  ]
}